While eye patches have long been the beauty industry’s secret to hydrating and de-puffing the under-eye area, disposable ones are pretty wasteful. If you’re looking for a sustainable alternative to save money without sacrificing results, you might want to try one of the best reusable eye patches. Reusable under-eye patches can be customized to meet your skincare needs, but they’re not one-note.
Shop the Best Reusable Under-Eye Patches
While single-use options are often packed with high-quality ingredients specifically designed for the under-eye region, the reusables serve as a blank canvas for your skincare routine. “They are designed to be used in combination with your preferred serums and creams to enhance the efficacy and absorption of such products,” explains Lauren Penzi, a board-certified dermatologist serving patients in Manhattan and Plainview, New York. “You can also customize your routine by using whatever is suitable for your under-eye skin’s current status and needs, which can definitely change over time.”
Another thing to love? Unlike disposable patches, which can sometimes be made with a flimsy paper or gel, reusable patches are built to last. “They may also be more durable and of a higher-quality material,” adds New York dermatologist Blair Murphy-Rose.
To help narrow down your search, check out our list below of the best reusable under-eye patches to add to your cart, according to experts.
Pros
Long-lasting- Lightweight
Cons
- Though long-lasting, these patches are very thin.
Get the most mileage out of your reusable patches with this popular set from Dieux. Not only are these silicone patches built to last up to a year with proper care, they also get the job done. “These are super lightweight, so they feel very comfortable when worn,” Penzi says. “Patients rave that their under-eyes appear plumper and smoother after each use.” In a 30-day customer perception study, 90 percent of participants said the skin around their eye was softer after using these twice a day for 10 minutes at a time.
Customer review: “After using these patches multiple times a week for the past couple months, I can confidently say that I love these!! Super easy to clean and have remained sticky! Can easily be used with any eye cream.” —JPackle
| Material | Silicone |
|---|---|
| Uses | Up to one year |
Pros
- Affordable
- Made with eco-friendly ingredients
- Comes in a storage tin
Cons
- Some shoppers say the patches are too big.
- Can fall off if not applied properly
As this option from Pacifica proves, you don’t need to spend top dollar on a great under-eye mask. When they’re cleaned and cared for properly, you can use these about 10 times, averaging around $1.50 per use. (That’s less than your morning cup of coffee.) Of course, Pacifica’s reusable patches have a lot more to offer than affordability. “These are super affordable, made of 100 percent silicone, and are vegan and cruelty-free,” Penzi says. “They are able to create a vacuumlike seal between your serum and your skin, helping to seal in the ingredients and boost hydration.”
Customer review: “I have not worn overnight, but have allowed to stay on for more than an hour when my under eyes were extra puffy and allergic. These really help when paired with the caffeine serum and keeping the eye pads in the refrigerator. I see improvement and happy to have less waste than the standard throw away pads.” —DawnFelice
| Material | Silicone |
|---|---|
| Uses | About 10 |
Pros
- Comes with storage case with compact mirror
- Offers cooling sensation
Cons
- Storage case’s battery does not last long
- Some say the patches don’t get cold enough.
At just under $50, these under-eye patches from Skn by Conair are by no means cheap; however, they might be a worthy investment for anyone who wants to turn this simple skincare step into a luxurious experience. In addition to the silicone eye patches, which can be used up to 30 times, this pick comes with a chargeable storage container that can provide up to three hours of cooling time. (The case even has a built-in mirror, so you can always check your reflection.)
Customer review: “I absolutely love this. I use it every morning before I apply my makeup. It calms my eyes down from a restless nights sleep, but the cooling sensation you get from it feels really nice. The patches stick very well and do not slip.” —Gina F.
| Material | Silicone |
|---|---|
| Uses | 30 |
Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below
Best for Sensitive Skin
Skin Gym Under-Eye Reusable Patches
Pros
- Gentle enough to be used on sensitive skin
- Easy to clean
- Come with storage container
Cons
- Though some people found these patches feel great out of the refrigerator, others say they don’t stay cold.
Anyone with sensitive skin knows they have to be very careful about what they put on their faces, including masks. Skin Gym’s reusable patches stay in place, and many shoppers have found they’re also suitable for sensitive skin. Even better? They're dermatologist-approved. “Made of medical-grade silicone, these are great patches that hold up really well over time with repeat use,” Penzi says. “They stay in place really well and are easy to clean after use.”
While Skin Gym doesn’t disclose how many uses you can get out of these patches, some customers claim they’ve worn the same set up to 40 or 50 times.
Customer review: “These are wonderful and don’t irritate my sensitive skin as most other products do. I’ve been suffering from eczema for the past few years, even around my eyes, which makes them extremely dry. These are a Godsend so I can get my eyes settled down and able to add tinted moisturizer before I go out for the day.” —Sally
| Material | Medical-grade silicone |
|---|---|
| Uses | Up to 50 |
Pros
- Eye and smile patches are great for fine lines
- Can be used overnight
Cons
- Some people say they lose their stick easily.
- Resealable bag is not the most protective
If you’re looking for a reusable eye patch that can pull double duty, Murphy-Rose says these reusable patches from SiO are a “great choice.” Not only are they made with a reusable, medical-grade silicone—so they can can used up to 10 times—they also come with matching patches for your smile lines. Simply place these over your favorite treatment before you go to bed, and you’ll kiss those fine line goodbye while you’re sleeping.
Customer review: “I can tell a huge difference after the 2nd night sleeping with them on. easy to reapply. If you follow the instructions, they will last. Very comfortable; have no issues sleeping with them on.” —Tonya
| Material | Silicone |
|---|---|
| Uses | 10 |
Pros
- Built to lock in ingredients and moisture
- Come with storage tin
Cons
- Some say these patches irritated their skin.
Give your skin a much-needed hydration boost with the help of 4AM Skin’s Overtime Under-Eye Masks. Though you might see these patches all over TikTok, it’s safe to say they're worth the viral hype. Suitable for all skin types, this silicone set is specifically built to lock in ingredients and reduce trans-epidermal water loss. Translation: If you’re looking for your lotions and potions to stay put and do their job, these patches might fit the bill.
Customer review: “I can’t get enough of 4am under eye masks. They have changed my under eye skin and best for travel because they stay on your face!” —River H.
| Material | Silicone |
|---|---|
| Uses | N/A |
Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below
Best for Cooling
Nyx Professional Makeup Face Freezie Reusable Cooling Under-Eye Patches
Pros
- Offers a cooling sensation
Cons
- Some people say these patches don’t lie flat on your face.
What could possibly be better than snagging a great set of reusable under-eye patches that save you money and resources? How about if the patches also emit a cooling, oh-so-soothing sensation? That’s where Nyx’s Face Freezie patches come in. These silicone patches are made to be stored in your refrigerator or freezer, so they’ll keep their cool when applied. (Psst—if you want to improve those chilling results, the brand recommends pairing these patches with its Face Freezie Primer.)
Customer review: “I got sun poisoning all over my face while on vacation and these came in very handy! My face swelled up and these helped bring it back down! And aside from that, they are very soothing.” —Brenna
| Material | Silicone |
|---|---|
| Uses | N/A |
Meet the experts
- Lauren Penzi, M.D., is a board-certified dermatologist based in Manhattan and Plainview, New York.
- Blair Murphy-Rose, M.D., F.A.A.D., is a board-certified dermatologist specializing in facial rejuvenation at the Laser & Skin Surgery Center of New York and a clinical instructor of dermatology at Weill Cornell Medical College.
What should you look for in reusable under-eye patches?
When it comes to shopping for the best reusable under-eye patches, longevity is key. While some options are made with hydrogel, you’ll find that most popular pairs use tough (and sometimes medical-grade) silicone. While silicone is typically a durable material that keeps its stick, you’ll want to research how long the patches you’re considering will last. Brands will often list how many uses you can get out of one pair, and you can often find additional information in customer reviews.
Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below
How do you use under-eye patches?
While directions will vary by brand, reusable under-eye patches typically work by placing a thin layer of your cream or serum on the skin underneath your eyes. Next, you’ll want to wait a few seconds, and then apply your patches. “Place the reusable patch on top and push down with gentle pressure to create a seal,” Penzi says. “Typically, these are left on for about 15 minutes, but always follow the instructions provided with your eye patches or the skincare product.”
Which ingredients go best with under-eye patches?
One of the best things about reusable under-eye patches is that you can pair them with a co*cktail of creams and serums to cater to your specific skincare needs. But what ingredients go best with these masks? “Humectants are great under the eye, as they hydrate and plump,” Murphy-Rose says. “Look for hyaluronic acid and glycerin, among others, to help hide fine lines. Topical antioxidants are excellent for protecting against signs of aging over time.” She also recommends avoiding formulas with harsh chemicals or added fragrances, to keep irritation to a minimum.
How do you prolong the life of your reusable under-eye patches?
If you want to get the most bang for your buck, taking proper care of your reusable under-eye patches is important. For Murphy-Rose, that means using them in moderation. “There are several ways to use eye patches incorrectly, including using them for too long or too frequently,” she says. “Eye patches should be worn no more than three times weekly.”
Penzi also recommends washing your patches with soap and water after each use and storing them in a dry, clean place like a carrying case.
Advertisem*nt - Continue Reading Below
More beauty favorites from Bazaar editors
- The Best Under-Eye Patches to Minimize Puffiness, Dryness, and More
- The Best Weighted Eye Masks You’ll Never Want to Take Off
- The Best Eye Creams With SPF for Easy Sun Protection
- The Best Eye Serums for Hydration and Dark Circles
- The Best Eye Creams for Wrinkles and Crow’s Feet
Why trust Harper’s Bazaar?
For more than 150 years, Harper’s Bazaar has been the preeminent fashion and beauty resource for women at every age. We cover what’s new and what’s next in beauty by working with the world’s leading authorities in dermatology, plastic surgery, cosmetics, skincare, hair care, and fragrance. Every story we publish has been thoroughly researched and vetted by our team of beauty editors and industry experts.
Kelsey Mulvey
Kelsey Mulvey is a freelance lifestyle journalist, who covers shopping and deals for Good Housekeeping, Women's Health, and ELLE Decor, among others. Her hobbies include themed spinning classes, Netflix, and nachos.
